Flat illustration of two matching government buildings facing each other, joined by a looping arrow over a tightrope of small bar-chart blocks, symbolising the tug-of-war between the SEC and the CFTC over stock perpetual futures.

SEC backs CFTC in the fight over who regulates stock perpetual futures

The SEC filed an amicus brief defending the CFTC, sued on 3 November by an alliance including Cboe and Citadel over approvals of single-stock perpetual futures. A judge denied emergency relief but questioned the CFTC’s legal basis.

The Securities and Exchange Commission has stepped into the fight over single-stock perpetual futures, filing an amicus brief this week in support of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. The CFTC was sued on 3 November by the Capital Markets Alliance, an industry group whose members include the exchange operator Cboe and the trading firm Citadel Securities. The dispute decides which regulator polices a new derivative tied to individual U.S. stocks, and whether crypto-native venues can list it.

What the case is really about

The CFTC approved single-stock versions of perpetual futures after a 45-day review, classifying them as security futures under the Commodity Futures Modernization Act of 2000. That label lets them trade on CFTC-regulated exchanges. The Capital Markets Alliance argues the contracts are really security-based swaps and belong under SEC jurisdiction.

The crux is delivery. A futures contract traditionally obliges delivery at some future date. Perpetuals never expire, so the plaintiffs argue there is no delivery obligation at all, and calling them futures stretches the definition past its limit. The CFTC’s approvals were deemed granted on 2 November.

Who lined up on which side

The SEC filed for the CFTC, pushing back against the idea of a “CFTC gone rogue” and an “SEC gone missing,” and stressing that it reviews CFTC rule changes and works with the agency closely. Coinbase, Kalshi and Kraken parent Payward, together with DRW Holdings, Jump Trading and Paradigm, sought leave to file a joint brief backing the CFTC.

On the other side sit Cboe and Citadel Securities through the Capital Markets Alliance, joined by the advocacy group Better Markets and former SEC commissioner Allison Herren Lee, who argue these products are securities swaps that need the SEC’s investor protections.

Who wins and who loses

For now the products keep trading, but their legal footing is unsettled. Coinbase, Kalshi and Payward have applications on file to list equity perpetuals, deemed approved on 2 November, so a court loss would hit the firms moving fastest into equities. Cboe and Citadel win if the approvals are vacated and the products move under SEC rules, a heavier compliance burden that favours incumbent exchanges.

What the court has signalled

On 3 November, U.S. District Judge Valerie Caproni denied the alliance’s request for a temporary restraining order. But the denial rested on the absence of imminent irreparable harm, not on the merits. The judge indicated the plaintiffs were likely to succeed on their statutory argument, a signal that cuts against the CFTC even as the emergency request failed.

What is still unknown

No final ruling has landed. The court has not said whether it will accept the outside briefs, how the plaintiffs’ reply answers the statutory objections, or what relief it will grant. Nor is it settled whether the crypto firms themselves would keep listing equity perpetuals if the rules tightened. Both sides describe an open question, not a result.

What to watch

The next steps are the court’s decision on the amicus briefs and its ruling on the alliance’s request to vacate the approvals. Until that lands, an approved product is not a settled one, and the question of who regulates stock perpetuals in the United States has no answer yet.

Be the first to leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *