Flat editorial illustration of two figures walking free from a courthouse past an oversized orange Ethereum diamond while dim robotic trading bots sit over a cracked glowing relay cable

MEV Brothers Acquitted in $25 Million Ethereum Case as Judge Finds No Fraud

A Manhattan federal judge acquitted the Peraire-Bueno brothers over a $25 million Ethereum MEV exploit, ruling prosecutors never proved a material lie. The first US criminal MEV case ends without a conviction.

A federal judge in Manhattan has acquitted two MIT-educated brothers accused of extracting $25 million from Ethereum trading bots, ending the U.S. government’s first criminal case over the practice known as maximal extractable value (MEV). U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke granted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno a judgment of acquittal, clearing them of wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering.

The ruling, issued Nov. 16 and reported Nov. 17–18, closes the case without a second trial and directs the clerk to end it. The decision lands a year after a jury deadlocked and Clarke declared a mistrial in November 2025.

Twelve seconds and $25 million

Prosecutors said the brothers ran a scheme in April 2023 against “sandwich” bots — automated traders that profit from MEV by placing their own orders on either side of other users’ transactions. According to the government, they deployed bait transactions to identify victim bots, exploited a flaw in the MEV-Boost relay software to release a proposed block early, then reordered that block to their advantage. The bots lost about $25 million, and the extraction took roughly twelve seconds.

The brothers were arrested in Boston and New York in May 2024. Each count carried up to 20 years in prison. Prosecutors also alleged they used shell companies and foreign exchanges to obscure the origin of the funds.

Why the judge threw it out

The court’s reasoning turned on a single legal element: wire fraud requires a material misrepresentation, and Clarke found none. In her opinion, the bait trades made no promise because “no trader who places a transaction in the public mempool would agree to be sandwiched.” A falsified signature failed, she wrote, because the relay never checked the altered fields, so it “had no effect on the behavior of its recipient.” Because the money laundering conspiracy count rested on the fraud finding, it fell too.

Clarke was explicit about the limits of the decision, writing that the question was not whether the brothers’ conduct was moral or violated uncharged laws — only whether the evidence could support a conviction on the charges brought.

Who wins and who loses

The brothers win outright: no conviction, no retrial, the case closed. The broader winner may be the MEV industry. If outwitting trading bots is not fraud, then many strategies that regulators and victims have treated as gray-area mischief sit further from criminal liability. The losers are the sandwich-bot operators who lost about $25 million and, with the criminal case gone, face no obvious path to recovery. Prosecutors, who pursued the first-of-its-kind charge and spent years on it, walk away empty-handed.

What is still unknown

Three questions remain. First, whether victims pursue civil claims, where the legal test is far lower than in criminal law. Second, whether regulators respond by targeting the infrastructure — relays and block builders — rather than individual traders. Third, how broadly the “no terms of use” logic reaches: a judge who says Ethereum’s rules impose no enforceable promise is a precedent that cuts well beyond this single exploit.