Grafico de velas mostrando movimientos de precio

0.1% of accounts take 67% of the profits: the uncomfortable side of prediction markets

Prediction markets have become crypto’s favourite toy. Platforms where you bet on whether Bitcoin will rise or fall, who wins an election, or when a particular law will pass. The pitch is attractive: aggregated information, prices that reflect real probability, and a layer of “this isn’t gambling, it’s forecasting”.

The data on the other side of the table tells a different story.

The figure no platform puts on its homepage

According to Wall Street Journal research published in May 2026, on Polymarket 0.1% of accounts take 67% of the profits, and more than 70% of users lose money.

Read that again. It is not that most people win a little: most people lose, and the winnings concentrate in a tiny fraction of accounts. That is not a prediction market aggregating wisdom. It is a market where a few professionals extract value from a crowd that believes it is informed.

And this is not an opinion about whether you like these platforms. It is the structure of the game.

Candlestick chart showing price movements
Image: Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

The problem that should actually worry you: changing the rules mid-flight

Worse than losing money on a bet you misunderstood is losing it on a bet where the platform changes the terms after you have already placed it. Polymarket has a documented track record of doing exactly that.

This is different from a volatile market. In a volatile market the price moves and you accept the risk. Here what moves is the definition of what you are betting on. And if resolving a market depends on how the platform interprets a news story, your probability analysis is worth precisely nothing.

Before trading on any of these platforms, look for one specific thing in their terms: what happens if the event occurs ambiguously, who decides the resolution, and whether they can void the market. If the answer isn’t clearly written down, you already know what you’re dealing with.

The regulatory map almost nobody shows you

While reviews talk about fees, regulators have been moving in parallel:

  • Brazil banned Polymarket and other prediction markets on 26 April 2026.
  • The UK Gambling Commission upheld an illegal-gambling sanction against Polymarket in July 2026, dismissing its appeal.
  • Lithuania blocked the first site of this kind on 22 October 2026.
  • In the United States, Democratic lawmakers introduced a bill in March to crack down on prediction markets, while several states and the federal government have sued each other over their bans.
  • Nevada cited a Massachusetts ruling in an attempt to shut Polymarket down in its territory.

In other words: legality depends on where you are, and it changes. A country that lets you trade today can block the site next month, and then your balance is on the wrong side of a border.

The risk that never makes the fee comparisons: the oracle

These markets don’t resolve themselves. Someone feeds the real-world data into the contract: an oracle. On decentralised platforms (Augur, Omen, Zeitgeist) that piece is the most fragile part of the whole system, because it decides who gets paid.

A badly designed oracle doesn’t get it wrong occasionally: it gets it wrong at the exact moment there is money on the line. And when that happens, the discussion stops being financial and becomes a governance problem that almost never resolves quickly.

Questions worth asking before you deposit

  1. Who resolves the market, and from what source? If it isn’t written down, the platform doesn’t know either.
  2. What does it cost to get in, and above all to get out? Add fees, spread and withdrawal. All three, not one.
  3. Is there liquidity in the market you want? An empty market with a lovely price is a price nobody will pay you.
  4. Where is the company, and which law applies to it? That matters more on the day you want to withdraw than on the day you deposit.
  5. Can they change or void the market? If the answer is yes, your analysis isn’t about the event: it’s about the platform.

The uncomfortable conclusion

Prediction markets can be a fascinating information tool and, at the same time, a terrible place to put your money. Both things are true simultaneously.

The aggregated price of a large market is often a decent estimate of a probability. But the market estimating well does not mean you will make money trading in it: the data says that on these platforms almost everyone loses and a tiny fraction takes it all.

Treat them for what they are: a mix of bookmaker, financial market and governance experiment. And as in any bookmaker, the only question that matters before you walk in isn’t how much you can win. It’s who is on the other side, and what edge they have over you.

Profit-concentration figures from the Wall Street Journal analysis of Polymarket and Kalshi (May 2026). Regulatory status per public records from Brazil (26 April 2026), the UK Gambling Commission (July 2026), Lithuania (22 October 2026) and press coverage of the US bill (March 2026). Regulation changes: verify current status before trading.

Be the first to leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *